Equity compensation is one of the most powerful tools companies have to attract, retain, and motivate talent. While it can be complex, a clear understanding of the fundamentals can transform equity from a misunderstood perk into a key driver of employee engagement, strategic alignment, and long-term business performance. This article offers a foundational yet technically grounded look at equity compensation, drawing on Infinite Equity’s experience in plan design, financial reporting, and education, with practical examples across award types.
Why Equity Matters
A well-designed equity program serves both tactical and strategic goals:
- Engage Employees: Foster ownership and a stake in shared outcomes.
- Compete for Talent: Essential in startup and growth environments where cash is constrained.
- Reward Performance: Drive alignment with company KPIs and shareholder value.
- Retain Key Talent: Promote long-term commitment through vesting.
Studies, including the General Social Survey (Kruse & Blasi, Rutgers), show that employee-owners exhibit higher levels of productivity, loyalty, and satisfaction.
What Is Equity Compensation?
At its core, equity represents ownership in a company. When companies grant equity to employees, they are offering a stake in the company’s success. Equity can take many forms, including:
- Restricted Stock Units (RSUs): Grants that convert into company shares upon vesting, with no purchase required. RSUs are taxed as ordinary income upon vesting and are often settled in shares or cash.
- Stock Options (ISOs and NQSOs): The right to buy shares at a predetermined price after vesting. ISOs may receive favorable tax treatment but are subject to holding period rules and AMT exposure. NQSOs are taxed at exercise.
- Performance Stock Units (PSUs): Shares awarded based on achievement of performance goals. Payouts can range from 0% to 200% or higher.
- Stock Appreciation Rights (SARs): Rights to the increase in stock value over time, often cash-settled. Can be a flexible alternative to options.
- Employee Stock Purchase Plans (ESPPs): Programs allowing employees to buy stock at a discount, often with a lookback feature. Qualifying dispositions may benefit from capital gains treatment.
Each award type carries distinct accounting, tax, and shareholder implications—making design and administration highly strategic.
Key Plan Elements and Terms
To participate in an equity program, employees typically receive:
- An Equity Plan Document: Governs the structure and rules of the program.
- An Equity Grant Agreement: Specifies the terms of each individual award.
Vesting defines when an employee earns the right to their award. Common vesting types include:
- Time-Based Vesting: Linear (e.g., 25% annually) or graded (e.g., 25/25/50%)
- Cliff Vesting: 100% vesting after a set period (e.g., one-year cliff)
- Performance-Based Vesting: Tied to internal metrics (EPS, revenue)
- Market-Based Vesting: Tied to external measures (stock price, relative TSR)
Understanding the vesting type is critical for accurate expense recognition under ASC 718.
Understanding the Award Types
Stock Options:
Allow employees to purchase shares at a fixed “exercise price”. Options only have value if the market price exceeds the strike price.
- Grant: 60 options at $10 strike
- Vesting: 100% in Year 4
- Market Price in Year 6: $30
- Value if exercised: $1,200 (60 x $20 spread)
ISOs may be eligible for capital gains treatment, but subject to a $100K annual limit and holding rules.
RSUs:
Convert to shares automatically at vesting. Employees owe taxes based on FMV at vest.
- Grant: 100 RSUs
- Vesting: 25/year over 4 years
- Stock Price at Vests: $30, $15, $35, $19
- Total Value Delivered: $2,475
RSUs are easy to understand and ideal for broad-based programs.
PSUs:
Linked to performance metrics, with payouts ranging from 0–200%+.
- Grant: 100 PSUs
- End Stock Price: $150
- Shares Delivered: 200 (200% target)
- Value: $30,000
PSUs are typically granted to executives or senior level employees.
ESPPs:
Offer purchase discounts (up to 15%) and lookback provisions. Can create significant value with favorable tax treatment if held.
- Start Price: $20, End Price: $25
- Purchase Price: 85% x $20 = $17
- Gain: 47% on day one
Popular in public companies; key tool for fostering ownership at scale.
Design Considerations for Equity Professionals
Compensation professionals should consider:
- Plan Scalability: As the company grows, do award types scale without undue dilution?
- Expense Forecasting: Is accounting aligned with expected performance outcomes?
- Dilution Management: Are you modeling burn rate and overhang by award type?
- Global Equity Challenges: Are local tax/treatment rules considered for each jurisdiction?
- Plan Governance: Are plan documents, communications, and grant practices audit-ready?
These questions should guide annual plan reviews and refresh cycles.
Building an Equity Culture
Equity only becomes meaningful when employees understand it. A robust education strategy should:
- Explain awards clearly at grant
- Visualize potential outcomes with modeling tools
- Offer resources before vesting, exercise, or purchase windows
When employees understand what they have, they’re more likely to value it—and behave like long-term stakeholders.
Accounting Considerations
ASC 718 governs the accounting for share-based compensation. Fair value is typically measured on the grant date and expensed over the requisite service period. For awards with:
- Service Conditions Only: Expense can be recognized using straight-line or accelerated attribution.
- Performance Conditions: Must use accelerated attribution. True-ups are required based on expected performance and payout.
- Market Conditions: Fair value includes the market hurdle (modeled via Monte Carlo), and no true-ups are allowed post-grant.
Final Thoughts
Equity compensation is a highly strategic lever. It can motivate, align, and reward—but only if it’s well-designed and well-communicated. By pairing technical accuracy with thoughtful education and governance, compensation professionals can transform equity from a compliance obligation into a cultural asset.
Whether you’re launching your first plan or managing a mature program across multiple countries, Infinite Equity supports companies in designing equity that works for your people and your business. Contact us today to learn more.
Global Insights: April Edition
Mastering Your Annual Grant and Vesting Process: A Strategic Guide
